My BEST Chocolate Pie

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cream Cheese Pie!

Recipe

Ingredients

• 2 pkgs cream cheese, softened

• 1 can sweetened condensed milk

• 6 oz chocolate syrup; I use the special dark kind

• 1 healthy dollop creamy peanut butter; be careful with this; too much and you have peanut butter pie; too little and the pie doesn't set up properly

• 1 graham cracker (or similar) crust; I use crushed pecans

Directions

• combine first 4 ingredients and mix thoroughly

• pour into pie crust and chill

• this will make more than enough filling for even a 10-inch crust

Early reports are that this is the best pie so far. It is currently in the fridge; we'll see if it sets properly.

8 hours later....

The pie set properly without being excessively heavy. The peanut butter is noticeable, perhaps a bit more so than I intended. You can still taste the cream cheese although you might not immediately identify it as such. All in all, MUCH better than the previous attempts at a Chocolate Cream Cheese Pie. In fact, this may be the best chocolate pie I've ever eaten, she said with all due modesty. Somewhat reminiscent of that famous chocolate and peanut butter candy....

Success at last -- Chocolate (Peanut Butter) Cream Cheese Pie 1.2, a quick and easy five-ingredient cream cheese pie. No more pies for a while; I eat too much of my experiments. Next, we're approaching chili season....

dks, 20 Oct 2025